Supreme Court Ruling Jeopardizes Wetland Protection

rick.savage • June 1, 2023

Dear Wetland Supporters:


I have bad news to share with you. The U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in the Sackett vs. the EPA has resulted in condemning many wetlands to unprotected status under the Clean Water Act. The details of the Sackett case are not important, but what the Supreme Court did was essentially rewrite the clean Water Act in a 5-4 decision with the descending opinions being shocked at what was done by the majority.


Loss of Federal Wetland Protection

The Sackett case has drawn upon the Justice Scalia opinion of the 2006 Rapanos vs. United States case which wanted to require more visual evidence of wetlands being connected to a navigable stream or river. The Rapanos case ended with a 4-1-4 decision with Justice Kennedy writing the Significant Nexus opinion to deal with Isolated wetlands, so the Justice Scalia opinion never took hold. But the Supreme Court ruling on the Sackett case has greatly narrowed wetland protection requiring visual evidence: If you don’t see water, how do you know it is a wetland (a jurisdictional wetland); if you see water, but the water does not connect to a navigable stream, then it is not protected; or if it is during the growing season, there may be no water, but during the winter there is plenty of water. Granted a lot of interpretation has to take place and those interpretations will likely be challenged in courts, so this is going to be a complex process to try to save and protect our wetlands.


During the Trump Administration, the Waters of the US (WOTUS) rule was rewritten based on Scalia’s opinion which resulted in about 50% of our Nation's wetlands losing protection under the US Clean Water Act. Court challenges kept the revised WOTUS rule from taking effect for most states. The Supreme Court ruling will result in more than 50% of the Nation's wetlands losing protection under the Clean Water Act. Honestly it is scary to think about how bad this could be for communities and wildlife that will be impacted by the lose and degradation of these waters.


North Carolina Wetland Protection

However, all is not lost at least in North Carolina where there is a state statute that says all waters of the state are under the jurisdiction of the state. During the brief implementation of the Trump WOTUS rule, the NC Department of Environmental Quality (NCDEQ) drafted rules for the state the be able to provide permitting (and protection) for wetland that were no longer federally protected. Those rules were approved by the NC Environmental Management Commission but were never approved by the Legislature (the rule is stalled by procedural disagreements with the Rules Review Commission). Therefore, these are “temporary rules” which are protecting these wetlands in North Carolina.


However, there is a bill in the NC legislature (senate), Farm Act. S.B. 582, North Carolina Farm Act of 2023, that has a provision to not protect wetlands any more stringent than federal protection. If this bill goes through with that wetland provision, it would be devastation to NC’s wetlands. It is important that this bill does not go through or that the wetland provision is removed.             


What can you do?

You, our supporters, can help by contacting your state senator and explain why wetlands are important and does not belong in this bill. Tell your representative that the state has allocated tens of millions of dollars to use nature-based solutions (including wetlands) to reduce flood impacts for our coastal communities, yet they would be undermining this effort by not protecting the very resources we need to mitigate and/or reduce flooding of our communities.  The Carolina Wetlands Association is working with the Southern Environmental Law Center, Sound Rivers, NC Wildlife Federation, and others to educate our legislatures on the need to protect our wetlands. You can greatly help this process by using these resources to voice your concern.


What about South Carolina?

In South Carolina, the state legislature can take steps to protect wetlands beyond those protected by the federal government. Local municipalities (unlike in NC) can also increase wetland protection within their jurisdiction.  It is important that we take action with our state and local legislators to be sure we protect our wetlands, which are vital to our well-being and critical to protecting us from flooding and water quality degradation.


So when visiting your favorite wetland, think: what if it were not protected and a developer wants to build

on it?


Rick Savage

Executive Director

Carolina Wetlands Association


You might also like

Celebrating Our Carolina Wetlands

By rick.savage July 7, 2026
July is Lakes Appreciation Month, an annual celebration led by the North American Lake Management Society (NALMS) to recognize the many ways lakes enrich our lives—from providing drinking water and recreation to supporting wildlife and local economies. It is also an ideal time to recognize one of a lake’s most important, yet often overlooked, partners: lacustrine wetlands. When many people picture a lake, they imagine open water stretching to the horizon. But healthy lakes are much more than open water. Around their shorelines lies a dynamic transition zone where land and water meet. These shallow, vegetated areas are known as lacustrine wetlands, and they are among the most productive ecosystems in the Carolinas. What’s the Difference Between a Lake and a Wetland? Although they are closely connected, lakes and wetlands are not the same. A lake is generally a body of open water deep enough that sunlight cannot always reach the bottom. In contrast, a wetland is defined by the presence of water at or near the surface long enough to support hydric soils and plants adapted to saturated conditions. Lacustrine wetlands occupy the shallow margins of lakes where water levels fluctuate seasonally. Because sunlight reaches the bottom, these areas support an abundance of native aquatic plants such as pickerelweed, arrowhead, bulrushes, and water lilies. Rather than competing with lakes, these wetlands help lakes function as healthy ecosystems. Think of them as the lake’s living shoreline. Nature’s Water Filter Before rainwater reaches a lake, it often flows through wetlands. Along the way, wetland plants slow runoff, trap sediment, absorb excess nutrients, and filter pollutants. This natural treatment system helps improve water clarity and reduce harmful algal blooms. The same wetlands also soften the impacts of floods by temporarily storing stormwater and slowly releasing it after heavy rains. As we have discussed in recent newsletters, healthy wetlands provide one of our most cost-effective defenses against flooding while protecting downstream communities. A Haven for Wildlife Lacustrine wetlands are biodiversity hotspots. Their shallow waters provide spawning and nursery habitat for fish, breeding grounds for amphibians, nesting areas for turtles, and feeding habitat for wading birds. Dragonflies patrol above the vegetation while pollinators visit native flowering plants along the shoreline. Many species spend their entire lives within these wetlands, while others depend on them during critical stages of migration or reproduction. Remove the wetland, and the lake loses much of the biological richness that makes it special. Carolina’s Lake-Associated Wetlands Across North and South Carolina, remarkable lake-associated wetlands demonstrate this close relationship between lakes and wetlands. The majestic cypress-gum swamps surrounding Lake Waccamaw create habitat for rare plants and animals found nowhere else. The extensive shoreline wetlands of Lake Mattamuskeet, the largest natural lake in North Carolina, support hundreds of thousands of migratory waterfowl each winter. Reservoirs such as Jordan Lake , Falls Lake , and Lake Norman also contain valuable coves, embayments, and shallow wetlands that provide wildlife habitat while improving water quality. Closer to home, many neighborhood lakes, farm ponds, and municipal reservoirs include wetland fringes that quietly perform these same ecological services every day. While these wetlands may seem ordinary, together they form an important network that benefits both people and wildlife. Some of our Wetland Treasures such as Merchants Millpond , Robertson Millpond , and Phelps Lake Shoreline are Lacustrine wetlands. Appreciating the Whole Ecosystem As you celebrate Lakes Appreciation Month, take a moment to look beyond the open water. Notice the cattails swaying along the shoreline, the chorus of frogs after sunset, the great blue heron stalking fish in the shallows, or the dragonflies darting among the lilies. Those vibrant edges are not simply the border of a lake—they are an essential part of the ecosystem. Protecting lakes means protecting the wetlands that surround them. Together, they improve water quality, reduce flooding, support biodiversity, and provide countless opportunities for recreation, education, and inspiration. At the Carolina Wetlands Association, we believe that every wetland matters—whether it borders a coastal marsh, a forested swamp, or a favorite Carolina lake. This July, as we celebrate Lakes Appreciation Month, let’s appreciate these remarkable partnerships between lakes and wetlands and continue working to conserve them for future generations. What is your favorite lake with beautiful wetlands? Share your photos and stories with the Carolina Wetlands Association and help us celebrate the wetland treasures that make our Carolina lakes so special. So go out and explore a wetland at your favorite lake or at one of our Wetland Treasures and remember that Carolina Wetlands Association is actively working to protect all wetlands. Your support is always appreciated. Rick Executive Director Carolina Wetlands Association
By Becky Ryon July 4, 2026
Buffers and Setback adopted by Cities and Towns
By rick.savage June 9, 2026
Hello Wetland Supporters, I hope everyone had a wonderful American Wetlands Month in May and found an opportunity to get outside and explore a wetland. We enjoyed fantastic paddling events at Robertson Millpond Preserve and Lake Mayo, where participants experienced the beauty and importance of these unique ecosystems firsthand. Wetlands have also been in the news recently as the impacts of recent Supreme Court decisions on wetland protections continue to be evaluated. Two recent articles highlight what is at stake: Lisa Sorg in Inside Climate News, Supreme Court’s Limitation on Wetlands Protection Will Make Flooding Worse Jesse Gourevitch and Adam Gold, New Research Shows What’s at Stake When Wetlands Disappea r The central message of both articles is clear: the loss of wetlands leads to increased flooding and rising economic costs for communities. Research cited by Gourevitch and Gold found that wetland loss across the United States has increased residential flood insurance claim payments by an estimated $10.1 billion since 1985 — approximately 9% of all insured riverine flood losses nationwide. The authors also emphasize that policymakers must better recognize the economic value wetlands provide in reducing flood damage to homes and communities. According to the research, the flood-mitigation value of currently unprotected wetlands is estimated at $177 billion nationwide , with North Carolina accounting for approximately $4.6 billion of those benefits . This research reinforces what the Carolina Wetlands Association has long understood: healthy wetlands are essential infrastructure for resilient communities. Through support from the NC Land and Water Fund, Carolina Wetlands Association have received three grants to partner with vulnerable communities to assess flooding concerns and develop restoration plans that incorporate community input, scientific data collection, and hydrologic modeling to identify the most effective wetland restoration strategies. We are also excited to share that we recently received a fourth NC Land and Water Fund grant to begin our first restoration project at Stony Run in Harnett County. Stony Run Walkable Watershed Lumbee Cultural Center Wetland Restoration By working alongside communities and restoring wetland resources, we are helping reduce potential flood damage while also providing additional benefits such as improved water quality, recreation opportunities, shoreline stabilization, environmental education, and greater community resilience. So, the next time you explore a wetland, remember that healthy wetlands mean healthy communities — and your support plays an important role in protecting these valuable ecosystems. Wetlands truly do matter. Best, Rick Savage Executive Director